Hamptons residents and visitors alike absolutely love Goldberg’s Famous Bagels. This family-owned bagel place is a go-to in The Hamptons. Opt for your favorite bagel and spread combo or try one of Goldberg’s creations like the Spicy Hobo.
Pop-Up Bagels is new to The Hamptons bagel scene, having gone viral in the last few years. Order ahead on Sunday for the week for pick up or drop off on whatever day you choose! Be sure to check out Pop-Up’s website each week to add specials to your order. Although there are no bagel sandwiches on the menu, Pop-Up does the classic bagel and smear combo fantastically.
25 W Neck Rd., Shelter Island / 631.749.5363 / Website
Located on Shelter Island, Eccentric Bagel has lots of unique bagel sandwich options, served all day. Start your morning with a savory-sweet bagel sandwich like The Ferry, or try out the shop’ signature “The Eccentric” sandwich.
Order a box of breakfast for delivery straight to your home. Curate your own box of bagels for you and a few friends and family, or for your next brunch party! Choose your favorite smears, bagels and toppings and create a bagel bar at home.