Just like the rest of New York, the Hamptons takes its bagels very seriously. Here are our picks for the best bagel spots in the Hamptons.
Elevate your bagel with Citarella’s lox.
CITARELLA
Undeniably the most famous gourmet grocer in the Hamptons, Citarella takes its culinary expertise to the next level with a stellar selection of bagel toppings. Known for fresh seafood, prime meats and artisanal groceries, Citarella caters to the discerning tastes of locals and summer visitors. Adorn its bagels with Citarella's homemade whitefish salad, smoked salmon or cream cheese. The toppings and possibilities are seemingly endless. Multiple locations,citarella.com
The options are endless at The Eccentric Bagel
THE ECCENTRIC BAGEL
The Eccentric Bagel emerged on Shelter Island as a local hub for bagel lovers. Run by Darryn Weinstein, the establishment is known for its handcrafted artisan bagels made from scratch daily. Its vast breakfast sandwich menu is nothing short of impressive, satisfying bagel cravings with locally inspired clever creations like The Ferry, Wades Beach, Hay Beach and much more. The team ensures every visit is memorable by blending Inventive designs, flavorful food and an enjoyable atmosphere. 25 W. Neck Road, Shelter Island,eccentricbagel.com
GOLDBERG'S FAMOUS BAGELS
The Goldberg family has a longstanding tradition in the bagel industry that dates back to 1949. Over four generations, they have become integral to the evolution of bagels, laying the groundwork for this doughy chain of bagel stores. Conveniently located in almost every town, these bagels are satisfyingly rich and flavorful, ideal for any time of day. With fluff y and golden-brown bagels with famous spreads and schmears to match, these bagels have become many locals' morning fixes. Multiple locations,theoriginalgoldbergsbagels.com
THE GOLDEN PEAR
Boasting a crunchy and crisp selection of bagels and flagels, The Golden Pear has established itself as the ultimate breakfast spot in the Hamptons culinary scene. Golden brown and fresh from the oven, these chewy delights can be elevated with toppings from applewood smoked bacon to salmon cream cheese and beyond. All bagels at the iconic green storefronts are loaded with seeds for an extra crunch, whether at Southampton, Bridgehampton or East Hampton kitchens. Multiple locations,goldenpearcafe.com
poppy seed bagel with cream cheese at Goldberg’s Famous Bagels
POPUP BAGELS
PopUp Bagels began as a humble project in a backyard, initially created to share a unique bagel recipe among friends. It has since expanded, focusing on delivering fresh, highquality bagels. Its product promises a perfect bake with a crispy outer crust and a soft interior, achieving a balance in size and seed distribution. Hamptonites can get a taste of its soft and fluff y inside and satisfyingly dense texture at its first Amagansett storefront for this summer. Meeting House, 4 Amagansett Square, Amaga popupbagels.c m Amagansett, com
Photography by: PHOTO COURTESY OF BRAND; PHOTO: BY JEN GOLDBERG
