Sam MacKinnon, Rachel Feinblatt, Camille Cauti Sam MacKinnon, Rachel Feinblatt, Camille Cauti | April 13, 2023 | Food & Drink, Feature, Guides,
When it comes to bakeries in the Hamptons, it can be hard to pinpoint a favorite. These 6 shops do an amazing job of providing a wide variety of delicious options.
There’s no better smell than the one lingering around the Wainscott Village Shopping Center. Levain is obviously the culprit of this sweet aroma, from their world-famous, baked-to-order cookies. They are ooey, gooey, and most certainly chewy. 354 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott
Tate’s Bake Shop founder Kathleen King embodies versatility on the Hamptons baking scene. “My vision of the Hamptons is families and beach barbecues and simple living and fresh fruit pie,” she says. “The farms are my heritage, my blood. The deeply rooted, all-American homestyle baked good is who we are. It wasn’t made up. It wasn’t thought of as a marketing tool, since that’s who we were.” 43 North Sea Road, Southampton
Calling all focaccia lovers. Espresso Da Asporto has the best Italian-inspired sandwiches around. The focaccia is truly unbeatable; its thickness and texture goes with any meat and cheese of your choosing. Espresso Da Asporto is also known for its famous house-made dressing, which complements any of the awesome eats. We love the convenient location for a grab-and-go ‘wich at breakfast, lunch or dinner. 2 Main St., Sag Harbor
The bread expertise here is no joke. Since 2011, this local favorite has been shaking and baking in the kitchen to produce the flakiest sourdough and baguettes in the area. Currently operating as a takeaway bakery, sandwich fans know this is the perfect place to find lunch or a picnic treat. The famous pickle bread is definitely worth a try, and since the menu is available for domestic shipping, you have no excuse to go Carissa-less. 221 Pantigo Road, East Hampton
Westhampton Beachers know that Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe is in a league of its own. Its expertise in the field of sweets does not go unnoticed-- the owners have kept this business up and running for more than 30 years, attracting a league of devoted customers in the process. If pie is not your thing, the cheesecake is also worthy of note. 112 Main St., Westhampton Beach
Bridgehampton, East Hampton, and now Montauk is home to East End's most delicious bakers. While the farm's prepared foods are known to be the best in town, the dessert lineup is even stronger. Sweet and irresistible, Lisa, Claire, Shelly, and Dianna wake up every morning to bake the ultimate pies and sweet specialties that cause some serious fanfare and lines that can sometimes wrap around the entire parking lot. 184 Three Mile Harbor Road, Easthampton
Adjacent to the iconic and delightful Pierre’s in Bridgehampton, Pierre’s Market is a cute and quick, run-in market, perfect for a yummy smoothie or a quick croissant! Whether you’re looking for a healthy salad or a homemade ice cream treat - Pierre’s market, an offspring of the iconic full-service restaurant, has it all. Located right on Bridgehamptons main drag, this convenient, yet adorable market will be the best start to your morning Out East. 2468 Main St, Bridgehampton
A New York City staple now Out East–Citarella prepares the most delectable baked goods, premade platters, fresh foods and more. With three locations in The Hamptons, Southampton, Easthampton, and Bridgehampton, you can’t miss Citarella on your trip down Montauk Highway. Whether you’re curating a dinner party spread or just shopping for your own sweet tooth, Citarella has everything you’ll need this summer season! Multiple locations
A Southampton classic - Ye Olde Bake Shoope bakes fresh, made to order pastries, cookies, cakes, and more. In the mood for a coffee chat, or just to do some work on a summer Friday? Try the cinnamon roll and a fresh iced coffee, it’s sure to put you in the best mood! Make sure to stop by Ye Olde Bake Shoppe next time you’re summering in Southampton. 17 Windmill Ln, Southampton
Photography by: Florencia Rosenfield/Unsplash