By Rachel Feinblatt By Rachel Feinblatt | October 9, 2024 | Food & Drink, Food & Drink Feature, Food & Drink, Food & Drink News Latest,
From the classic chocolate chip to innovative creations that meld unexpected ingredients, these bakeries add a unique twist to the cookie jar. Here, we round up the best chocolate chip cookies on the East End.
Chubba Whubba’s stuffed Oreo cookie.
BEACH BAKERY & GRAND CAFE
Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe is a haven for sweet treats, offering an irresistible array of baked goods to satisfy any craving. From classic black-and-white cookies with their perfect balance of chocolate and vanilla icing to the indulgent chocolate chunk cookies packed with gooey, rich chocolate pieces, every bite promises a delightful experience. These treats aren’t just delicious—they’re crafted with care, using high-quality ingredients that make every visit feel like a special occasion. 112 Main St., Westhampton Beach,beachbakerycafe.com
CARISSA’S BAKERY
Carissa’s Bakery is rewriting the rules of the baking game, bringing a fresh twist to classic cookies that will make your taste buds dance. Imagine the bold flavors of matcha almond or the surprising combination of miso and chocolate chunk—available at all three Hamptons storefronts. With stores in East Hampton and Sag Harbor, Carissa’s isn’t just keeping up with the bakery scene—it’s leading it with creativity and flair. Multiple locations,carissasthebakery.com
CHUBBA WHUBBA BAKERY
Baked with love and a sprinkle of magic, Chubba Whubba Bakery is the ultimate recipe for sweet-tooth success. Its flavors are far from the ordinary—they’re stuffed to the brim with fun, unexpected flavors like Oreo-packed chocolate chip, gooey peanut butter, s’mores, dark chocolate sea salt and much more. Available to ship anywhere and deliver locally in the Hamptons, these cookies are the kind of indulgence where calories simply don’t count. @chubbawhubbabakery
LEVAIN BAKERY
Welcome to Levain Bakery, the cookie kingdom of the Hamptons, where nearly 30 years of cookie magic await. Immerse yourself in a world of indulgence with gooey chocolate chip walnut cookies, decadent dark chocolate chip cookies, classic oatmeal raisin cookies, rich dark chocolate peanut butter chip cookies and various other sugary delights. 354 Montauk Highway, Wainscott,levainbakery.com
PIERRE’S
In the Hamptons culinary scene, one name stands out in particular—Pierre’s. Whether savoring the moment at its restaurant or delighting in culinary confections from its market, there’s no doubt that an almond- and chocolate-covered raspberry cookie will end your visit on the right note. 2468 Main St., Bridgehampton,pierresbh.com
WINDMILL LANE BAKERY
When your sweet tooth goes into overdrive, hop over to the Hamptons’ newest sugar haven—Windmill Lane Bakery. Th is bakery will surely delight with its incredible array of cookies, from classic chocolate chip to epic cookie platters, and everything in between. No matter your dietary needs or flavor cravings, there’s something for everyone, with vegan and gluten-free treats that ensure everyone in the Hamptons can indulge in some delicious fun. 17 Windmill Lane, Southampton,windmilllanebakeryandcafe.com
Photography by: PHOTO COURTESY OF BRAND