If you’re craving a cold treat, here are 13 of the best ice cream shops in the Hamptons.
See also: 8 Dock and Dine Destinations in The Hamptons
View this post on Instagram
35 Newtown Lane, East Hampton / Website
What’s the scoop in East Hampton? Since the summer sun calls for an extra dose of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, A La Mode Shoppe brings the Newtown Lane scene the best of the best with a cherry on top. From the bustling streets of the Big Apple, this adorable, all-inclusive ice cream shop features an assortment of refreshing 100-percent nut-, egg- and sesame-free flavors–think delectable flavors like pink sprinkle, cooks and partly cloudy
View this post on Instagram
2391 Montauk Hwy., Bridgehampton / 631.537.9885
Sometimes the best things are left classic. That is why Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen has one of the strongest ice cream games out East. The restaurant is nothing short of adorable, radiating ultimate ice cream parlor vibes. Needless to say, their homemade ice cream hits the sweet spot, with flavors ranging from mint chocolate chip to coffee chip. After munching on one of Candy Kitchen’s signature lunch dishes or when in need of a refresher, their ice cream makes for the ultimate sweet treat. Top your ice cream with a sugar confection that puts the candy in Candy Kitchen.
View this post on Instagram
125 Main St., Sag Harbor / 631.808.3888 / Website
Some people channel their inner zen at a yoga class, others find it with a cup of fro-yo in hand at BuddhaBerry in Sag Harbor. Their frozen yogurt selection is sourced with high-quality ingredients and topped with offerings from around the world. With no artificial colors, dyes or flavoring, their selection makes it almost too easy to indulge. From a triple cookie smash-up to Buddha’s best berry, their flavors also accommodate allergies and dietary restrictions.
View this post on Instagram
67 Main St., Southampton / 631.283.8108 / Website
The Fudge Company, located in Southampton Village, has the best fudge in the game—they even have it in their name! Step into their sweet tooth wonderland, filled with an array of candy, ice cream and fudge, of course! Their expertise in the field of sweets does not go unnoticed—they have kept this business in the family since 1973.
View this post on Instagram
2414 Main St, Bridgehampton / 631.488.7692 / Website
Sundaes on Main is your one-stop shop for all sweet-tooth-related inquiries, as its delicious candy, ice cream and confections make this local favorite a haven for all sugar lovers. Try out the Dole Whip Pineapple for an ultra-refreshing treat, or opt for soft-serve classics such as chocolate and vanilla. Dairy-free options such as the Perfectly Pleasant Pomegranate make Sundaes on Main inclusive of everyone.
View this post on Instagram
40 NY-27A, Southampton / 631.283.9752 / Website
Since 1958, this family-owned luncheonette has been whipping up American classics such as burgers, cole slaw and homemade ice cream. Served malted, in an ice cream soda, in a milkshake, as a sundae or in a cone or cup, Sip ‘N Soda’s ice cream is legendary among Southamptonites. We recommend grabbing a sandwich while you’re there, the chicken salad is excellent!
View this post on Instagram
69 N. Main St., East Hampton / 631.604.2382 / Website
For the loyal Hershey’s Chocolate fans out East, MOO MOO’s East Hampton Ice Cream Shop is a must-try. The parlor has an array of Hershey’s ice cream, curated with quality ingredients in each of their 12 flavors. Moose tracks, milk and cookies, cookie monster, cappuccino crunch and cookie doughlicious are a few of the shop’s flavors that Moo Moo fans salivate over. Pro Tip—Dip any flavor in Hershey’s chocolate syrup for the ultimate sugar high.
View this post on Instagram
99 Main St., Westhampton / 631.553.0155 / Website
Brace yourself, because Shock Ice Cream and Dessert Cafe will be an ice cream experience like no other. Their famous carnival cone is a must-try—cotton candy topped with a cone and the ice cream and toppings of your choosing. What could be better? This Instagrammable hot spot is filled with bright colors, friendly faces, and even a giant ice cream sculpture. Be sure to stop by the attached clothing store as well.
View this post on Instagram
716 Montauk Hwy., Montauk / 631.238.5690 / Website
Don’t let the name deceive—Sundae Donuts takes the best of both desserts for a killer donut-infused ice cream bar. Flavors such as dulce de leche, chocolate peanut butter and birthday cake have us coming back for more. As if ice cream with pieces of donut in each bite didn’t sound good enough, Sundae Donuts offers plenty of toppings. We recommend coming with friends, as you’ll want to try as many flavors as possible.
View this post on Instagram
106 Newtown Lane, East Hampton / Website
This brand-new frozen yogurt and candy shop is bringing all of the throw-back vibes through its mom-and-pop feel and classic confections. 15 different flavors of self-serve frozen yogurt, including non-dairy options, ensures that everyone can have exactly what they’re craving. Be sure to try the homemade cookies while you’re there!
View this post on Instagram
139 W. Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays / 631.594.5600 / Website
There’s nothing quite like gelato on a hot summer day, and Gemelli Gelato always hits the spot. We love their inventive flavors, such as banana with Nutella, caramel cookie batter and rainbow cookie. Take your gelato to the next level with a flavored waffle cone, with flavors including cinnamon brown sugar, red velvet, lavender, birthday cake and more. Want something more refreshing? Opt for the sorbet!
View this post on Instagram
677 Montauk Hwy, Montauk / 631.668.5515 / Website
This beloved Montauk burger joint serves up delicious homemade ice cream crafted daily, with tons of delicious flavors available. Our favorites include coffee Oreo, cherry vanilla, banana fudge and peanut butter blast. Indulge in creating your own sundae complete with a cherry and whipped cream or add toppings such as hot fudge, peanuts, chocolate syrup and more.
View this post on Instagram
478 W. Lake Drive, Montauk / 631.238.5430 / Website
This new addition to Montauk is serving up delicious frozen yogurt in the cutest storefront. With near-endless toppings and drool-worthy flavors, there’s something for everyone at Sundae Fundae. Hang out at their outdoor picnic tables after grabbing your froyo and enjoy the gorgeous Montauk scenery.
Next time you're craving a sweet treat, give one of these Hamptons' favorites a try.
Photography by: foodandstyle / iStock
