Summer calls for tortilla chips, guacamole and a margarita, so here's our list of the best Mexican restaurants in the Hamptons.
See also: The 10 Best Wineries Near The Hamptons
View this post on Instagram
1615 Bridgehampton-SagHarbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor / 631.725.1045 / Website
Estia's Little Kitchen has long been a delicious part of the Hamptons scene, and no wonder—their honest, fresh, comforting Mexican-American dishes have long honored the local bounty. Add to that the fresh vegetables grown in Estia's private garden that appear on summer dishes, and Estia's Little Kitchen is a can't-miss spot. Authentic paella, turtle rolls and tortilla soup are highlights at this family-style spot with a standout breakfast.
View this post on Instagram
74 Montauk Highway, Amagansett / 631.267.8800 / Website
Honest Management’s La Fondita serves traditional Mexican street food in an authentic outdoor setting. The wide variety of taco options leaves customers with difficult choices but no bad options. Insider tip: Before you leave, be sure to pick up bottles of the housemade hot sauces.
View this post on Instagram
2 Main St., Sag Harbor / 631.800.8226 / Website
Chow down on inventive, healthy and delicious tacos at this neighborhood locale overlooking the water. Everyone’s favorite Sag Harbor Mexican eatery serves dishes from tacos to fajitas, but their prized plate is the Impossible Chorizo. Vegan-approved and undeniably delicious, this dish consists of K Pasa vegan chorizo, pickled red onion and radish.
View this post on Instagram
74A Montauk Highway, Amagansett / 631.267.5709 / Website
La Fondita's sister restaurant, Coche Comedor, is where you want to take a date for Mexican food. The chicken adobo is perfect for sharing, be it with a special someone, friends or family. Served in half and whole chicken portions, the chicken adobo will delight and satiate, with hearty potatoes, onions and jalapeños.
View this post on Instagram
28 Maidstone Park Road, East Hampton / 631.329.3663 / Website
Known for its delicious margaritas, gorgeous outdoor seating and mouthwatering raw bar and tacos, Rita Cantina is a no-brainer for East Hamptonites. With local ingredients and an agave-focused bar program, what’s not to love? We highly recommend the lobster ceviche tostada with a side of grilled Mexican street corn.
View this post on Instagram
83 Main St, Westhampton Beach / 631.288.5252 / Website
Since 1999, this Westhampton staple has been serving up delicious Mexican cuisine and a lively atmosphere. The menu brings some unexpected delights (think mozzarella sticks and pretzel sticks), making Margarita Grille a great option for large groups. Naturally, you can’t skip the margaritas, but this joint serves up a mean mojito as well.
View this post on Instagram
62 Main St, Sag Harbor / 631.899.4646 / Website
Newer to the scene, this Sag Harbor hot spot boasts a well-priced menu full of authentic Mexican recipes crafted with fresh local ingredients. Each of the bright, flavorful dishes is delicious, but we particularly love the Mexican cowboy, a bowl filled with grilled carne asada, avocado, beans, corn, tomato and cabbage, and the Cerdo, a bowl with glazed pork belly, avocado, pickled onion and jicama.
View this post on Instagram
33A Main St., East Hampton / 631.329.2583 / Website
Blue Parrot has quickly become a beloved East Hampton spot for authentic Mexican cuisine. This vibrant eatery offers a well-priced menu filled with fresh, local ingredients that bring each dish to life. Among the standout offerings, the lobster cobb is a favorite, featuring a hearty mix of Montauk lobster, avocado, blue cheese, egg, tomato, crisp romaine and jicama, topped with a peppercorn dressing. Blue Parrot promises a delightful dining experience that keeps its East Hampton crowd coming back for more.
View this post on Instagram
10 Windmill Lane, Southampton / 631.377.3050 / Website
El Verano made a grand entrance into the Hamptons culinary scene, quickly becoming a go-to destination in Southampton for those seeking delicious and authentic Mexican flavors. The menu is a testament to the use of fresh ingredients, offering dishes that are full of vibrant taste. Chef Julian Medina brings a twist to dishes like almejas, Spanish for clams, by combining them beautifully with chorizo, poblano peppers and breadcrumbs. El Verano offers a culinary journey that celebrates the best of Mexican cuisine in every bite.
The next time you're craving food with the delicious flavorings of Mexican cuisine, look no further than these 9 hot spots that are sure to hit the spot every single time.
Photography by: Noah Fecks for Rita Cantina
