Amaya Henry Amaya Henry | September 23, 2024 | Food & Drink, Feature, Guides,
Bee Sting pizza at Robeta's Montauk
New York is known for its pizza, and Hamptonites take their pies very seriously. Luckily for us, the Hamptons are home to some truly delicious pizza joints, from upscale dining to a classic divey pizza experience. These 12 slices are sure to wow you and your tastebuds, and you'll be back for more in no time.
See Also: The 6 Best Italian Restaurants In The Hamptons
36 Newton Lane, East Hampton / 631.324.5900 / Website
Sam Nasca and his family opened Sam's in 1947 and it has served East Hampton residents ever since. Because of its welcoming ambiance and first-rate service, Sam’s has grown into a beloved East Hampton spot. Their delicious pizzas come with tomato sauce, mozzarella, romano cheese and oregano. The Sam's Special, one of their specialty pizzas, has sausage, onions, garlic, peppers and mushrooms and is guaranteed to be a crowd favorite.
103 Main St., Westhampton Beach / 631.998.3323 / Website
Enjoy the freshest ingredients at 103 Bambino’s. Every day, they prepare their own dough, black-label housemade tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella. All other ingredients are either locally sourced, fresh or imported from Italy. Stop by during the weekdays for their daily specials like Margherita pizza Monday and pepperoni pizza Tuesday. Along with the traditional options, 103 also offers inventive pizzas like the clam pizza topped with fresh shucked clams, fresh garlic butter, lemon zest and woodfired Italian breadcrumbs.
61 Main St., Westhampton Beach / 631.288.3003 / Website
Savor the crisp, wood-fired crust of the pizzas at Brunetti Pizza, where choices are easy to make. They take a step out of the decision-making process by listing which wines/beers go best with each pizza on their menu. Talk about a lifesaver! Their signature Vongole pizza includes fresh shucked, chopped local Long Island clams, garlic, white wine, herb butter sauce and fresh parsley, paired with Fiano wine and Torrente beer.
104 Park Place, East Hampton / 631.324.5751 / Website
With the slogan, “always a warm welcome and a hot slice,” who wouldn’t want to dine at Fierro’s Pizzeria? We know you’ve heard about the Grandma’s slice, but what about the Grandpa’s slice? This pizza keeps it simple with marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil. At Fierro’s, they continue to expand and supply their neighborhood with pizza while several generations work to establish its proud history.
752 Montauk Highway., Montauk / 631.668.8256 / Website
One of the greatest eateries in town for quality pizza is Alimentari Beach. The food is thoughtfully made, and the ingredients are always fresh. You'll want to return for more for sure! As a nod to the company's Italian roots, their burrata pizza has caramelized organic tomato sauce, Lioneli burrata and fresh cracked ground pepper, and if you really want to hone into the Italian side, you can add prosciutto for an additional $7.
2095 Montauk Highway., Amagansett / 631.668.8378 / Website
What’s better than a dive bar that serves pizza? When you come up with an answer, let us know. Built on the foundation of “great pizza, cold drinks, and good music," you can’t ask for much more. This expansive bar and pizzeria has both indoor and outdoor seating with a strong focus on summer nightlife. Major sporting events are broadcast on flat-screen TVs, along with a constant stream of surf and skate footage. At Dive Bar Pizza, they offer both specialty and classic pies along with pizzettes (a small pizza that’s half the size of a regular-sized pizza.) On Friday and Saturday enjoy pies or pizza by the slice until 2:00 a.m. or until they run out!
341 Pantigo Rd., East Hampton / 631.604.2227 / Website
A house from the 1880s has been beautifully renovated and is now home to Moby's. This East Hampton gem serves seasonal Italian cuisine and cocktails. Enjoy pizzas created with fresh, local ingredients like the summer squash pizza with whipped ricotta and squash blossom or the funghi pizza with wild mushrooms, fonduta and arugula.
240 Fort Pond Rd., Montauk / Website
At Roberta’s in Montauk, pizzas are cooked Neapolitan style with top-notch mozzarella and on-site-cured meats are available. While the restaurant offers much more than just pizza, their pies are still among of the best in the Hamptons. We all love a good laugh and pizzas with names like Marissa Tomeito, Uruala's Parade, and White Guy, though the crowd favorite is the Bee Sting, crafted with tomatoes, mozzarella, soppressata, basil, chili and honey for the perfect sweet and savory pie.
237 Main St., Amagansett / 631.394.5654 / Website
Fini PIzza brings a Brooklyn favorite to the Hamptons. Their Amagansett location mimics the classic NYC slice shop to offer unique eating experiences for all customers by honoring history, appreciating the present and investing in the future of their community. Whether you choose the NY or Sicilian, you're sure to walk away with a full stomach and a happy heart. Don't forget to try their Fini heat sauce for an added kick!
432 W Lake Dr., Montauk / 631.668.5555 / Website
Despite being a relative newcomer to the Italian scene, Kenny's has already established itself as a mainstay. Since opening in 2020, they have provided guests with an appealing variety of delectable, authentic Italian dishes. Their pizzas are made in their Romana-style gourmet brick oven leaving the crust nice and crispy. In addition to the classic margarita pizza, they have specialty pizzas like the San Danielle and the Ortolana.
54 S Erie Ave., Montauk / 631.668.1601 / Website
What does it take to make a good pizza? A blade and some salt…among other things. At Blade and Salt, 16-inch pizzas and slices of cheese and pepperoni are available. Their version of a white pizza is known as Pizza Bianca and has spinach, mushrooms, ricotta, pecorino romano and garlic. For our gluten-free friends, any of their pizzas (except Grandma style) can be made gluten-free for an additional charge.
44 Three Mile Harbor Rd., East Hampton / 917.225.6668 / Website
Little Charli might be new to the Hamptons, but it's hardly new to the pizza scene. Since 2004, Little Charli has been a favorite in NYC, and rightfully received its laurels upon expanding out East this past summer. These wood-fired pizzas are packed full of flavor thanks to toppings such as soppressata, spicy honey, truffle, burrata and shallot. Open until 11 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays, its no surprise this East Hampton haunt has quickly become a staple in the Hamptons pizza scene.
Photography by: BRANDON HARMON