At Modern Luxury, connection and community define who we are. We use cookies to improve the Modern Luxury experience - to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze our traffic. We also may share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. We take your privacy seriously and want you to be aware that we have recently made changes to our Privacy Policy, which can be found here.


5 Retro Cocktails By Hamptons Bartenders You've Got To Try

Isabella Canelli | December 1, 2020 | Food & Drink On the Town hamptons


Molecular mixed drinks making you concerned? Wine lost its cachet? Retro cocktails might be your next spirited adventure.

Big on nostalgia and familiar to your taste buds, these sipping standards stand the test of time - and for good reason. To maximize their appeal, we matched these old-fashioned concoctions with equally evocative establishments. Cheers to the old school!

See also: Here Are 4 Local Breweries With Fall Seasonal Beers


Hot Toddy: Hot water, whiskey, honey, lemon juice, cinnamon stick

Where: Moby’s; 341 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton;

Why: It gets a bit nippy at this East Hampton hot spot. A Hot Toddy is a great way to get the warm-up started. Be sure to enjoy yours near one of Moby's many outdoor heating lamps.


Martini: Gin, dry vermouth, olives

Where: East Hampton Grill; 99 N Main St, East Hampton;

Why: If the servers who switch out your Martini glass mid-drink to make sure it stays chilled aren't a good enough of a reason to visit East Hampton Grill, the huge olives and superb house gin used in this recipe should be.


Rum Old Fashioned: Rum, water, simple syrup, bitters, sliced orange

Where: Bell & Anchor; 3253 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor;

Why: Made with Diplomatico Reserva, a stripped-down version of this oldie but a goodie sans bells and whistles is as yummy as it gets, and the big-wow of a waterfront view at Bell & Anchor makes it even yummier.


Sidecar: Cognac, triple sec orange, lemon juice, sliced orange

Where: American Hotel; 45 Main St #3012, Sag Harbor;

Why: Though The Ritz in Paris claims the origin of this drink, the American Hotel in Sag Harbor may have perfected it. Delicious and rich, forthy and robust, it’s the ideal antidote to the mounted Moosehead jarringly overseeing the dining room activities.


White Russian: Vodka, Kahlúa, coffee liquor and cream

Where: Bobby Van’s; 2393 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton;

Why: What better place to indulge in an adult version of a milkshake than at this grownup steakhouse that takes its cocktailing culture very seriously.

Photography by: Helena Lopes/Unsplash, Yanita Jankovic/Unsplash, Stanislav Ivanitskiy/Unsplash, Paige Ledford/Unsplash, Nikita Tikhomirov/Unsplash, Yes More Content/Unsplash