By: Jordan Budney and Abigail Warwick By: Jordan Budney and Abigail Warwick | October 31, 2024 | Food & Drink, Feature, Guides,
Thanksgiving is all about catching up with friends and families, doing fun family traditions like football in the front yard, and of course, the food. Whether you are a side dish stan and cannot get enough of the mashed potatoes and stuffing, or portion your plate out for all of the turkey and meat, enjoy what these restaurants have cooked up specifically for this holiday season. See our picks for tons of options when it comes to nixing the cooking and celebrating Thanksgiving at a restaurant.
See Also: Top Pie Shops in The Hamptons
126 Main St., Sag Harbor / 631.725.0900 / Website
Known for its iconic wood-fired cooking and authentic simple cooking, Lulu’s Thanksgiving offerings will make you forget you are not nestled up by a fireplace at home. Curated by Chef Philippe Corbet, this special Thanksgiving feast menu is available for both dine-in and take-out with plenty of entrees and sides portioned for all families big and small. The entree special features roasted turkey with cranberry sauce, chestnut-sunchoke stuffing, sweet potato souffle, roasted lemon brussels sprouts and plenty of gravy. Save the stress about who brings dessert and throw in their apple tarte tatin into the package to complete the perfect meal.
405 Montauk Hwy., East Quogue / 631.653.6770 / Website
What began as a two-story speakeasy and stored liquor during Prohibition in 1910 was later converted into the highly praised restaurant known and loved today. Owners Christian Mir and Elaine Digiacomo fulfilled their dreams of opening a restaurant by buying the building back in 1996 and continues to serve as a local favorite in the Hamptons. The Thanksgiving 3-Course Prix Fix menu has dishes like tuna tartare, potato gnocchi ala Romana, roasted natural turkey and truffle mac and cheese. Most of the dine-in options are also available for take-out a la carte, including the cinnamon sugar donuts and pumpkin cheesecake, or skip the decision-making and order the family-sized Thanksgiving dinner package that serves up to four, plus leftovers.
91 Hill St., Southampton / 631.283.6500 / Website
After Thanksgiving dinner, the last thing anyone wants to be doing is commuting back home on crowded dark roads. Luckily, Claude’s Thanksgiving Special package includes their beautifully crafted Thursday night dinner, a hearty breakfast for the drive home the next morning and a place to take a turkey nap for two. For those families who enjoy more of a Thanksgiving lunch, enjoy a delicious and festive three-course meal from 1 p.m. to 5 p.m. starting at 48 dollars per person and 28 dollars for children under twelve. Although the menu has yet to be announced, snag your spot at the communal table now before reservations quickly fill up.
2468 Main St., Bridgehampton / 631.537.5110 / Website
Open seven days a week, 365 days a year for breakfast, lunch and dinner, this non-stop restaurant never passes on cooking a delicious Thanksgiving feast. Described as “hip, classic and festive from day one,” Pierre’s has been serving locals and tourists since 2002 and has never closed one day since. Pierre Weber comes from several generations of bakers and is sharing his vision of an elegant but casual establishment backed by the support of Euro-friendly New Yorkers and Hampton residents. They are expected to serve a traditional Thanksgiving dinner, including everyone’s tried and true roasted turkey, brussel sprouts, sweet potatoes and plenty of other side dishes that somehow always steal the show.
1 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton / 631.808.2001 / Website
Celebrate, mingle and unite for an unforgettable Thanksgiving dinner at this contemporary option nestled in the pictorial town of Bridgehampton. Whether you’re staying for the weekend or just dining in on Thanksgiving, you’re sure to enjoy the stunning views at Topping Rose House. The menu is filled with plenty of farm-to-table items to choose from for your holiday meal, ensuring a polished yet relaxed special occasion dinner. Stay tuned for more information regarding specific menu options, but in the meantime, plan to stay the weekend and partake in all of the wellness experiences this place has to offer.
143 Main St., East Hampton / 631.324.1770 / Website
Almost one hundred years before Thanksgiving was named a national holiday under Lincoln, 1770 House was converted into an inn and gained a reputation for its welcomeness and warmth. This classic and chic restaurant and hotel is the perfect place to spend your Thanksgiving and has a special Thanksgiving menu with a tasting menu of three courses. The first course features everything from Montauk scallop crudo to luxurious lobster bisque, followed by main courses such as the traditional organic Amish turkey with sage gravy. End the night with an apple cobbler, a sticky date cake or awaken those Christmas vibes with a dark chocolate and gingerbread tart.
290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk / 631.668.2345 / Website
Unfortunately, Scarpetta Beach will be departing on December 8 to make room for a new flagship restaurant set to open the following spring, so enjoy one final Thanksgiving tradition with the team. Where downtown Manhattan meets Montauk, take in the view of the beautiful beach while you enjoy your holiday meal at Gurney’s. For a final hoorah and a joyful celebration, give thanks over the exquisite dinner platters such as the roasted pumpkin salad, the roasted leek stuffed tortellini, and of course, the turkey. Be sure to snag a slice of pumpkin or pecan pie topped with berries, caramel and vanilla ice cream that always hits the spot.
31 W. Water St., Sag Harbor / 631.725.2100 / Website
Water-view dining paired with a wood-burning fireplace awaits on a cozy second-floor restaurant at this harborside escape serving up a fresh Thanksgiving tradition. This classic all-American dining room offers elevated takes on beloved Long Island fare and sources vegetables, fish and meats from a variety of farmers and artisans across the East End and beyond. Known for their extensive and award-winning wine lists, pair your Thanksgiving plate with a well-chosen assortment of quality-produced glass to ideally match the meal. Some dishes include spiced carrot soup, jumbo lump crab cakes, beach plum farm maple glazed ham and pumpkin pie topped with a pile of whipped cream.
Nothing beats making lasting memories and embracing the start of the holiday season surrounded by plenty of good food specially prepared at these incredible restaurants. After all, Thanksgiving is meant to be spent with loved ones, not scrubbing dishes and cleaning tables all night long.
Photography by: Andrew Zaeh / Getty Images
