Search Our Site

Where To Have Thanksgiving Dinner In The Hamptons

Abigail Warwick Abigail Warwick | October 23, 2023 | Food & Drink Feature Guides

thanksgiving.jpgSee our picks for tons of options when it comes to nixing the cooking and celebrating Thanksgiving at a restaurant in the Hamptons.

See Also: Top 5 Pie Shops in The Hamptons

American Hotel

45 Main St., Sag Harbor / 631.725.3535 / Website

A tried and true favorite whose holiday menu hasn’t been released yet, American Hotel is a go-to for Thanksgiving dinner. Start your meal with a welcome glass of prosecco and American-French cuisine. Opt for a classic turkey dinner to celebrate the holiday or try something nontraditional, like the roast Scottish salmon.

Lulu Kitchen & Bar

126 Main St., Sag Harbor / 631.725.0900 / Website

A favorite of ours for a few years now, Lulu typically offers a family-style Thanksgiving meal including classics like roasted turkey with cranberry sauce and sweet potato soufflé. While Lulu’s holiday menu has not hit the website yet, you can’t go wrong planning your day of thanks here.

Claude's Restaurant

91 Hill St., Southampton / 631.283.6500 / Website

Although Claude’s is yet to announce its Thanksgiving menu, it typically offers a fantastic three-course dinner for just $42 per person. Stay the weekend at the Southampton Inn and enjoy the festivities over the weekend, which usually includes live music and a parade.

Pierre's

2468 Main St., Bridgehampton / 631.537.5110 / Website

A Thanksgiving meal that keeps everyone happy, Pierre’s offers a wide range of options on its holiday menu. Order a traditional turkey or even a burger, there’s something for everyone.

Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House

1 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton / 631.808.2001 / Website

For a contemporary option, make your way to Bridgehampton and enjoy a meal at Topping Rose House’s Jean-Georges. Whether you’re staying for the weekend or just dining in on Thanksgiving, you’re sure to enjoy the stunning views at Topping Rose House. Jean-Georges menu is filled with plenty of farm-to-table items to choose from for your holiday meal. Start your meal with butternut squash soup and end it with the obligatory spiced pumpkin pie.

1770 House

143 Main St., East Hampton / 631.324.1770 / Website

This classic restaurant and hotel is the perfect place to spend your Thanksgiving. 1770 House has a special Thanksgiving menu with a tasting menu of three courses. This year, enjoy a bite of selections from traditional turkey to sashimi to sticky date cake.

Good Ground Tavern

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Canoe Place (@canoeplace)

239 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays / 631.763.6300 / Website

For a more traditional Thanksgiving menu, head to Good Ground Tavern at Canoe Place Inn in Hampton Bays. Classic Thanksgiving sides are found on the holiday menu, including whipped potatoes and tri-color carrots. No need to cook an extravagant meal this year when you can enjoy a meal at this beautifully scenic location.

Scarpetta Beach at Gurney’s Montauk

290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk / 631.668.2345 / Website

Take in the view of Montauk’s Scarpetta Beach while you enjoy your holiday meal at Gurney’s. With a few selections for each course, you’ll get a Thanksgiving meal you’ll love. Be sure to try out the Dutch Apple Crumble for dessert to satisfy those fall taste buds.


Tags: holidays thanksgiving thanksgiving dining Apple News Abigail Warwick

Photography by: Andrew Zaeh / Getty Images